Ranked from the data
The four to look at first
Claw resistance counts one and a half times, accidents and traction one and a quarter each, hair and dirt once, with a small preference for materials mainly sold into homes; the four scores are the pet guide’s.
1
$6.00–$9.50 per sq ft installed
The default answer for dogs, and it earns it at a 20 mil wear layer: a waterproof core, a textured surface with real grip, and hair that sweeps straight off. The thin residential tiers scratch, and that is where every disappointed LVP owner with a dog went wrong. Insist on the mil rating in writing and lay the joints tight.
2
$7.50–$11.00 per sq ft installed
Glue-down vinyl tile is the same wear layer and the same waterproof body as rigid plank, fully bonded so a running dog cannot shift it and a damaged tile is cut out and replaced. It needs a flat subfloor and a professional; in exchange it is the tougher installation of the two.
3
$13.50–$24.00 per sq ft installed
Unmarkable by any claw and indifferent to any accident, and epoxy grout closes the one route urine has in. The catch is the surface: a polished porcelain gives an old or heavy dog nothing to grip, so choose a matte finish with a published DCOF figure, and put runners on the routes the dog actually uses.
4
$7.00–$11.00 per sq ft installed
The same waterproof, textured surface as SPC on a softer, warmer core that an older dog is kinder to. It dents more easily than a stone core under a dropped bone or a dragged crate, which is the only reason it ranks below SPC. For a house that is also full of people, it is often the better floor.